Cleveland Guardians’ Tyler Freeman reacts after being called out on strikes against the San Francisco Giants during the first inning at Oracle Park in San Francisco on Tue Sep 12, 2023 (AP News photo)
Cleveland (69-77). 100 002 000 – 3. 4. 0
San Francisco (74-71) 000 010 000. – 1. 6. 1
Time: 2:17
Attendance: 23,541
Tuesday, September 12, 2023
By Lewis Rubman
SAN FRANCISCO–If the baseball gods played hunches the way lottery players do, today would have been an auspicious one for the Giants. Sean Manaea, the one time front line starter for the one time talent laden Oakland Athletics, was on the mound in a rare start for a San Francisco team searching to extend its winning streak. Manaea’s numbers at game time? 5-5, with an ERA of exactly five earned runs per nine innings.
Tuesday he started out poorly but got his act together and didn’t let a runner reach base after getting the final out in the first and a one out single by José Ramírez in the sixth.
Manaea left with the bases loaded and two outs in that frame finished up the inning without allowing a run if it weren’t for LaMonte Wade’s fielding error on ground ball to first by Kole Calhoun. But Wade made his error, and Ryan Walker replaced Manaea and gave up a bases clearing single, with both runs charged to Manaea.
The starter ended up allowing three runs, two of them unearned and posthumous. He walked two, plunked one batter and struck out five. 56 of his 80 pitches were counted as strikes. Manaea didn’t deserve to lose this game, but he did, and his record now reads 5-6, 4.80.
The final 3-1 defeat left the home team only 1.5 games behind in the race for the last NL Wild Card spot, but its elimination number has dwindled to 16 with 17 games left in the season..
Cal Quantrill, who took the mound for Cleveland, also came with ugly season’s numbers, 2-6, 5.70. Unlike Manaea, who’d been used mainly in relief this year, the Guardian righty had started all of his 15 previous games. In his most recent attempt, hurled six scoreless innings against the Angels in Anaheim but went home with a no decision in a 3-2 loss last Thursday. He’s been on the injured list twice this year, which may explain to some extent his poor performances.
Manaea certainly pitched well tonight, going six innings and yielding only one run, which was earned, on five hits and three walks, while striking out two. He threw 86 pitches, 65 for strikes on the way to his third win against six losses while reducing his ERA to 5.40.
The Guardians got a jump start over a wild Manaea in the opening frame, converting a single, a pair of walks, and two failed double play conversions into a one run lead before the Giants took their first swing at the plate. It took him 33 pitches to do it, but Manaea finally caught Tyler Freeman looking at a called third strike to stop the bleeding then and there.
The Giants comeback attempt was foiled in their half of the third when Brandon Crawford fell victim to The Curse of the Leadoff double and died on third, which he’d reached on a weak ground out by Luis Matos.
Quantrill continued to thwart the Giant bats, and it wasn’t until there was one out in the fifth that San Francisco managed to get its second hit, but it was a significant one. Blake Sabol launched his 13th home run of the year, a 417 foot blast to right center that left his bat at 107.6mph. It came off an 89.2mph cut fast ball and tied the score at one all.
Cleveland took the lead back in their half of the sixth on Ramírez’s single, after which Josh Naylor forced him out at second, Manaea hit David Frey with a pitch. Then came Wade’s fatidic error that brought Ryan Walker out of the bull pen. Tyler Freeman tagged Walker for a single that drove in Naylor and Frey and put the visitors ahead, 3-1.
Walker got the third out in the sixth, notched a K and surrendered a single before giving way to Scott Alexander in the seventh.
Reynaldo López was on the mound for Cleveland when the crowd stopped singing “Take Me Out to the Bal Game.” He allowed a walk but nothing more and gave way to Trevor Stephan, who shut the Giants down, yielding only a single to Flores.
John Brebbia stifled the Guardians in the top of the ninth.
Cleveland sent in Emmanuel Chase, last night’s losing pitcher, to try to shut the Giants down for good in the bottom of the ninth. He did it, in 1,2,3 order.
The antagonists return tomorrow, Wednesday, at 12:45 for the rubber game of the series. The Giants will send heralded rookie Kyle Harrison (1-1, 4.87) against Cleveland’s Logan Allen (7-7, 3.68)











