San Francisco Giants Matt Chapman (left) is tagged out by Detroit Tigers pitcher Brenan Hanifee (right) in the bottom of the eighth inning at Oracle Park in San Francisco on Sun Aug 11, 2024 (AP News photo)
Sunday, Aug. 11, 2024
Oracle Park
San Francisco, California
Detroit Tigers 5 (56-63)
San Francisco Giants 4 (61-59)
Win: Keider Montero (3-5)
Loss: Hayden Birdsong (3-2)
Save: Will Vest (1)
Time: 2:52
Attendance: 40,447
By Stephen Ruderman
SAN FRANCISCO–Wasted opportunities and boneheaded base-running burned the San Francisco Giants, and Hayden Birdsong struggled, as the Giants were unable to complete the sweep and lost the series finale to the Detroit Tigers 5-4 on Sunday.
The Giants came into Sunday winners of 12 of their last 15. After finally getting to three games over .500 for the first time all season with their fourth-straight win Saturday, the Giants had a chance to complete the sweep on this beautiful mostly-cloudy afternoon at Oracle Park.
Sunday would be a test for young Hayden Birdsong. After a solid first six big league starts in which he didn’t allow more than three runs, he suffered his first bad outing in his last start in Washington on Tuesday. It doesn’t matter who you are; bad outings happen. The question is how Birdsong would respond Sunday.
Birdsong would be tested right away. Matt Vierling stepped up to begin the game, and he lined a home run to the first row out in left-center field to give the Tigers an early 1-0 lead. Birdsong then retired the side.
The Giants would be up against the young right-hander, Keider Montero in this pitching matchup of kids who made their major league debuts this season. Tyler Fitzgerald would be first up, and he led off the bottom of the first with a ground-rule double to right-center.
One thing was apparent early on: the ball was carrying today. LaMonte Wade walked, and Heliot Ramos got Fitzgerald to third on a flyout to right.
You gotta give credit to Fitzgerald. Tigers’ right-fielder Akil Baddoo made the catch in shallow right field and made a solid throw to third. It was pure gutsy base-running by Fitzgerald, and it paid off.
Michael Conforto walked to load the bases, and that brought up Matt Chapman. Chapman shot a base-hit into right-center, and two runs scored to give the Giants the lead.
Birdsong retired the first two men he faced in the top of the second, but Zach McKinstry singled with two outs, and that brought up Dillon Dingler. Dingler hit a high fly ball to right-center, and with the ball carrying the way it was today, it sailed into the Tigers’ bullpen, which put Detroit back ahead.
The Giants rallied in the bottom of the second. Jerar Encarnacion walked to start the inning, and Tyler Fitzgerald singled with one out.
Wade hit a fly ball to deep right-center, and Tigers’ center-fielder Parker Meadows made a tremendous running catch as he collided and even somewhat trampled over right-fielder Alex Baddoo. It was reminiscent of an iconic catch that Willie Mays made while leaping over Bobby Bonds in 1970, but this one came against the Giants, who ended up not scoring.
Birdsong pitched a scoreless top of the third and a 1-2-3 top of the fourth. Montero pitched 1-2-3 innings in the bottom of the third and fourth.
The Tigers have a lineup full of guys whose names you would have expected to see in a lineup in either the 19th Century, or in Star Wars. Considering that Sunday was Star Wars Day at Oracle Park, it made perfect sense. In the top of the fifth, those names did some damage against Birdsong.
Dillon Dingler, who hit the home run in the top of the second, led off the top of the fifth with a ground-rule double to right-center. Akil Baddoo got Dingler to third with a flyout to center, and Matt Vierling laced a double down the left field line to knock in Dingler and make it 4-2.
That did it for Birdsong, who struggled again Sunday. Birdsong did not struggle anywhere near as much as he did Tuesday in D.C., and he was burned by the fact that the ball was carrying Sunday, but it was still a rough outing.
Left-handed flame thrower Erik Miller came in, and after Bligh Madris hit a chopped back to the mound, Colt Keith got Vierling in with a base-hit to make it 5-2.
Montero threw a scoreless bottom of the fifth, and Miller ran into trouble in the top of the sixth. Miller walked Gio Urshela to start the inning, and two batters later, McKinstry walked to put runners at first and second with one out.
Bob Melvin brought in Sean Hjelle to face Dingler, who was 2-for-2 with the home run and ground-rule double. The Tigers were poised to blow this game open, but Hjelle and the Giants caught a break when Dingler hit a bullet right to Matt Chapman at third for the second out. Baddoo flew out to center, and the Giants were able to keep the deficit at three.
The Giants were able to stay in the game, and it paid dividends in the bottom of the sixth. Michael Conforto, who has been heating up here in August, hit one of the wall in left that he was able to leg out for a triple.
Some weirdness happened while Conforto was at third. As Montero was going into his motion, he stopped and was called for a balk, and Conforto was sent home. However, First Base Umpire D.J. Reyburn had called time, because center-fielder Parker Meadows was out of position. The umpires conferred and sent Conforto back to third.
No big deal. Conforto would score on a base-hit by Matt Chapman. Tigers Manager A.J. Hinch pulled Montero for Tyler Holton, and former Tiger Mark Canha drew a pinch-hit walk. However, Patrick Bailey grounded into a 5-4-3 double play, which seemed to snuff out the rally.
Chapman did go to third on the double play, as Jerar Encarnacion came up with two outs. Encarnacion lined a double the other way to right to score Chapman and make it 5-4.
Hjelle returned to the mound for the top of the seventh, as the Tigers threatened again. Andy Ibanez singled with one out, and Justyn-Henry Malloy walked with two outs.
Gio Urshela came up, and he hit a sharp chopper off the end of the bat to first. Wade dove to his left to come with it, and he flipped it to Hjelle to end the inning, as the Giants had dodged another bullet.
Holton and Brenan Hanifee combined for a scoreless bottom of the seventh for Detroit, and Taylor Rogers came in to throw a 1-2-3 inning for the Giants.
Chapman tripled to lead off the eighth, and the Giants had the tying run 90 feet away. The Tigers then played the infield in for Mark Canha, who hit a sharp ground ball to short. Despite the drawn-in infield, Chapman took off for the plate, and he was caught in a rundown for a crushing and embarrassing first out. Chapman sat at the plate in disbelief as he caught his breath.
Canha alertly took second on the play, but then he was caught in a rundown and tagged out when Bailey hit a chopper back to the mound. Back-to-back boneheaded base-running plays had single-handedly taken the Giants out of a rally, and Jerar Encarnacion grounded out to end the inning.
Jordan Hicks pitched through a pair of singles in the top of the ninth, and Hinch went to Will Vest in the bottom of the ninth. Vest retired the first two men he faced, but Wade worked a 1-2 count into a walk to extend the game for the potential winning run in Heliot Ramos.
Ramos was 0-for-4, and he was up there pressing, as he quickly fell behind 0-2. He then fouled off a fastball and took a changeup down for ball one, but he was caught looking at a 96-MPH fastball right on the outside corner to end it. Ramos had a few words for Home Plate Umpire Charlie Ramos—no relation—but Heliot Ramos had nobody to blame but himself there.
Keider Montero got the win; Hayden Birdsong took his second-career walk; and Will Vest got his first save of the season.
The Giants wasted a lot of opportunities Sunday, as they went 3-for-14 with runners in scoring position. Despite the run they have made, they have gone 31-for-161 with runners in scoring position since July 25. If that does not improve, you can forget about this team getting into October Baseball.
As much as the wasted opportunities hurt Sunday, once Chapman and Canha had their base-running blunders in the eighth, that pretty much sucked the life out of them.
“[I’m] disgusted at myself for doing that,” Chapman bluntly said, taking full ownership of his mistake like the true leader that he is.
Those were the postgame words of a man who went 3-for-4; knocked in three of the Giants’ four runs; and had two of the Giants’ three hits with runners in scoring position Sunday.
Now, the Giants will have to move on and be ready to go when the Braves come in for a crucial four-game series starting Monday night. Not only are the Giants currently chasing the Braves for the third wild card spot, but if the Giants can at the very least split this series, they will have a winning record against the Braves and will hold the tiebreaker.
However, with their schedule about to get much harder, the Giants really need to take three of four from the Braves. Another potential problem is that Jorge Soler will be making his return to Oracle Park after Farhan Zaidi traded him at the Deadline on July 30, and Soler will certainly be motivated to stick it to his former team.
Blake Snell (2-3, 4.31 ERA) will make the start for the Giants, and he will be opposed by veteran all-star left-hander Chris Sale (13-3, 2.75 ERA). First pitch Monday night will be at 6:45 p.m.
National League Wild Card Standings:
*1. Diamondbacks 66-53 +4.0
*2. Padres 66-53 +4.0
3. Braves 61-56 —
Mets 61-57 0.5
Cardinals 60-58 1.5
GIANTS 61-59 1.5
Cubs 59-60 3.0
Reds 57-61 4.5
Pirates 56-61 5.0
*Tiebreaking procedures taken into effect.