Giant lose season finale at Oracle 5-2 to Dodgers; Crawford plays final game for SF takes a curtain call

San Francisco Giants’ Brandon Crawford prepares for the pitch by Los Angeles Dodgers starting pitcher Bobby Millerm during the first inning at Oracle Park in San Francisco on Sun Oct 1, 2023 (AP News photo)

Los Angeles (100-62) 000 005 000. – 5. 7. 1

San Francisco (79-83). 000 001 010. – 2. 3. 0

Sunday, October 1, 2023

Time: 2:44

Attendance: 38,350

By Lewis Rubman

SAN FRANCISCO–This the way the world ends This is the way the world ends This is the way the world ends Not with a bang but a whimper. —T.S. Eliot, “The Hollow Men”

It wasn’t the end of the world, and the Giants’ season ended with both a whimper and a few bangs in a 5-2 loss to the NL West’s division winning Los Angeles Dodgers. Of course, one team’s bang is another team’s wimper, which is one of the beauties of baseball. Teams don’t compete to reach some abstract, context free goal; they play against each other.

Casey Stengel was right when he said that good pitching always beats good hitting and vice versa. The interplay between hitting and pitching, the confrontation, goes to the heart of the came. The Spanish philosopher José Ortega y Gasset’s dictum applies: I am myself and my circumstances.

Brian Crawford received a two minute standing ovation just before the first pitch was thrown at 1:06. He would be the Giants’ leadoff batter in the bottom of the first, having been reinstated from the IL to make what is very likely to be his farewell performance. It was Crawford’s 1,655th major league game, all of them as a Giant. The ovations came and went as frequently as the “SELL TEAM” chants do in Oakland or the exhortation to “BEAT LA” do in SF.

The last and loudest came as the ninth inning began and Crawford embraced his teammates and walked off the field, replaced by Marco Luciano at short. The old guard had passed. Crawford was the only remaining Giant from the 2014 World Series champions.

San Francisco sent their latest highly touted rookie, southpaw Kyle Harrison, to the mound. He had gone 1-1,4.85 in his brief, six game, career in the show. He plunked two consecutive batters but got through the first inning without any other trouble, which cleared the way for another ovation when Crawford came to bat and yet another when he went down swinging.

Crawford remained in the game and ended his career by going 0 for 4 with two strikeouts. My score card shows him making one put out and no assists.

Having righted the ship, Harrison returned to the mound in the second and pitched until John Brebbia relieved him to start the visitors’ sixth.

Harrison had gone five frames without allowing a hit, although he did hit his work after throwing five innings of no hit baseball, although he did hit three Dodgers with pitches and walk another two. It took him 94 pitches, 61 for strikes to get through the 20 Angelinos he faced. The youngster was not involved in the decision and so finished his first big season at 1-1, 4.15.

The Dodgers also sent a rookie to the mound. Bob Miller came to Los Angeles with three years of minor league experience, during which he went 10-10, 3.79. In the bigs, he had gone 11-4, 3.89 before today. His last previous start came on September 26, when he gave up two runs, both earned, to the Rockies over seven innings in Coors Field.

The Giants mauled him in his only other start against them, getting to him for seven hits and seven runs, all earned, in 5-2/3 innings. This afternoon he lasted a mere four innings against San Francisco, but he shut them out over that stretch, allowing only one hit and one walk.

His pitch count was 57, with 38 strikes. Victor González, who went on to garner the win and now is 3-3, 4.01, replaced him for the fifth and set the Giants down in order. Like Harrison, Miller to settle for. a no decision. He closed the book on the 2023 regular season at 11-4, 3.76.

John Brebbia replaced Harrison at the start of the visitors’ sixth and was ineffective. He faced three batters, the first and third of whom, Will Smith and Max Muncy, reached base on a single and walk, respectively. Both of them scored on singles allowed by Taylor Rogers, Brebbia’s. replacement, and the runs were charged to Brebbia. Kike Hernández’s home run to left, however, and the three runs batted in that came with it were all charged to Taylor’s account. Ross Stirling relieved replaced Taylor with Los Angeles ahead, 5-0.

Ryan Pepiot, listed as a starter, was on the mound replacing González for Los Angeles when Casey Schmidt led off the home sixth with a 377 foot round tripper to left, his fourth dinger in his short span with the Giants. That fig leaf made it a 5-1 ball game.

Schmidt made it two in a row when, leading off the Giants’ half of the eighth, he sent Pepiot’s first offering, an 88.3mph slider into the left center field bleachers, 389 feet from, which it left at 106.3mph.

Evan Phillips set the Giants down in order to earn his 24th save. Brebbia was the losing pitcher and ended his season at 3-5, 3.99.

The Giants’ next game is scheduled for Thursday, March 28, 2024, against the Padres in San Diego. The probable starters haven’t been announced yet.

San Francisco Giants podcast with Stephen Ruderman: Posey, Melvin, Wotus, Correa, who amongst them will be Giants next manager

Former San Francisco Giants catcher Buster Posey takes to the 2012 World Series celebration back on Oct 31, 2012. Posey has been named as a top candidate for manager for the Giants job. It’s unlikely that Posey will take the job according to sources as Posey left baseball to have more time with his family. (AP file photo)

On the SF Giants podcast with Stephen:

#1 Stephen wanted to go over some of the top candidates for the job of manager of the San Francisco Giants. We’ll start with Buster Posey nothing like name recognition. He’s a three time World Champion catcher and a no one would be surprised if he gets on a Hall of Fame ballot after the five year waiting period is up. Yet can Posey come in and manage the club with no managerial experience what would that adjustment be like?

#2 Bob Melvin is still managing the San Diego Padres but that all could come to an end. The Padres didn’t make post season and Padres GM AJ Preller and CEO Erik Greupner will be meeting Melvin Monday at Petco Park to discuss Melvin’s future. If Melvin gets canned in San Diego he’s been speculated as one of the top contenders for the Giants job. He managed a struggling Oakland A’s club and got the best out of a bad situation, he was a former Giants catcher and is well known and admired for his work in the Bay Area.

#3 Giants third base coach Mark Hallberg is considered the best candidate for the job. He’s well respected and has worked with all the players through his time as third base coach and the players would say he would be a fit. Hallberg was good friends with Posey and if Hallberg was named manager he might tab Posey to come back as a coach.

#4 Ron Wotus is a special assistant with the Giants and a fan favorite. Wotus has been coaching the team under managers Dusty Baker, Felipe Alou, Bruce Bochy, and now Gabe Kapler. Wotus spoke to the team after last Wednesday night’s game after the Giants lost giving up three runs in the top of the tenth inning against the Padres in a 5-2 loss. The writing was on the wall after that game. Did Wotus speaking with the team have meaning for the future for him as a possible manager.

#5 Stephen, just mentioning three more names that could come up available as manager the Rockies Bud Black, the Angels Phil Nevin, the Yankees Aaron Boone, and the Brewers Craig Counsell. Of that short list who do you see having a chance joining the helm at the Giants.

Stephen Ruderman was a MLB podcast contributor for http://www.sportsradioservice.com

Giants get the edge on Dodgers and Kershaw 2-1; Asian American managers make MLB history

San Francisco Giants interim manager Kai Correa stands in the dugout during the third inning as Correa and Los Angeles Dodgers manager Dave Roberts become the first MLB managers of Asian decent to oppose each other in MLB history at Oracle Park on Sat Sep 30, 2023 (AP News photo)

Los Angeles (99-61). 000 010 000. – 1. 8. 1

San Francisco (79-82). 001 001 00x. – 2 5 0

Time: 2:07

Attendance: 39,253

Saturday, September 30, 2023

By Lewis Rubman

SAN FRANCISCO—Well, two questions were answered last night. Yes, the Giants will finish the season with a losing record. No, Gabe Kapler will not be the team’s manager any longer. Bench coach Kai Correa will handle the orange and black’s managerial duties for tonight and tomorrow’s games.

His choice this evening in San Francisco’s 2-1 hard fought victory. over the division winning was 27 year old right hander Tristan Beck. Statcast calls Beck’s four seamer his best pitch. He throws it 36.6% of the time, and opponents have a .167 BA against it.

This was Beck’s third start of the season for the Giants. The first two were as an opener, but he went five full innings tonight and shut the Dodgers out in the first four of them. In all. This all, Beck allowed one run, and it was earned, on six hits and a walk.

He struck out three Dodgers, and 47 of his 70 pitches counted as strikes. The youngster faced 21 batters and went home with a no decision and a record of 3-3, 3.92. Ryan Walker relieved him to start the sixth. Walker would get the win, his fifth, against four defeats and bring his ERA down to 3.23.

The Dodgers sent an established star, Clayton Kershaw with a sparkling season’s record of 13-4, 2.42, to which a September earned run average of 1.93 contributed, to the mound as a tuneup for the oncoming postseason. The three time Cy Young Award isn’t only a strong candidate for that trophy; he’s a strong candidate for a trophy in Cooperstown as well. Kershaw pitched well tonight, but left with the Dodgers trailing 2-1 with one down in the bottom of the sixth.

Kershaw had faced 22 batters, throwing 83 pitches, 52 for strikes. He allowed two runs, both earned, in his 5-1/3 inning tenure on the mound. They came on two hits, two walks, and a wild pitch. He was tagged with the loss and will end the season at 13-5, 2.46.

The air was, as the cliché has it, rife with speculation about who will be Kapler’s eventual successor. Curtis Pashelka offered a list in this morning’s San José Mercury News. conveniently divided, like Gaul, into three parts. Those already on the Giants’ payroll are Ron Wotus, currently Special Assistant to Baseball Operations, with 36 years of service to the organization; third base coach Mark Hallbereg; and Correa.

Candidates not currently on the payroll but with ties to it or the bay area are Bob Melvin, in the likely event that he’s let go by underperforming Padres; one time Giants hitting coach and resent Texas Rangers bench coach and offensive coordinator Donnie Ecker; and Marin County’s Will Venable, who had been a candidate for the job at Oracle Park in 2019, but Kapler beat him out for it.

The one member of the group Pashelka calls “external candidates with prestige is Craig Counsell, whose contract with the Brewers is at the tail end of its last year.

You pays yer money and you takes yer cherce. Make mine Melvin.

There was little to choose between the way the two teams played in the first two frames. Each got one hit, a double, but nothing more in the first. (San Francisco’s two bagger came from Austin Slater, who suffered The Cure of the Leadoff Double). Each pitcher threw 13 offerings in the first and 11 in the second.

That situation changed in the home third. Rookie Tyler Fitzgerald set his second big league round tripper . It travelled 414 feet before landing in the left center field bleachers and came off a 72mph curve.

The Giants threatened to tack on to the 1-0 lead Fitzgerald’s blast provided them. Luis Matos and Thairo Estrada hit back to back singles that put runners on the corners with two down, but Estrada got caught trying to steal second, and that was that.

Elay tied the score in the top of the fifth on a one out down the line double into the right field corner by David Peralta and a two out double to left by the irrepressible Mookie Betts.

Poor fielding by Max Muncy contributed to San Francisco taking the lead and driving Kershaw from the mound in the bottom of the sixth, but Kershaw wasn’t faultless either. Slater led off with a base on balls and, with Matos batting, went to second on a wild pitch. Matos walked and was forced out at second on Estrada’s grounder to Muncy at third, where Slater arrived safely on the play.

Wilmer Flores then hit a bouncing ball to Muncy, who bobbled it two or three times. Flores reached first on the error, and Slater crossed the plate with the tie breaking tally. The run was earned, and the Giants’ first baseman was credited with an RBI, his 61st of the year.

That’s when Michael Grove replaced Kershaw. He held the Giants hitless through the seventh and was relieved by Caleb Ferguson, who set the Giants down in order in his inning on the hill.

Tyler Rogers, the right handed submariner pitched a crisp 1,2,3 top of the eighth.

Interim manager Correa called on Camilo Doval to try to earn his 39th save in 47 attempts. He got Jason Heyward to fly out to center. He fanned James Outman. Chris Taylor kept the Dodgers’ hopes alive with a clean single to left, bringing David Peralta to the plate. Taylor broke for second on Doval’s first pitch to Peralta, and Bailey threw him out, Estrada providing the tag.

Kyle Harrison (1-1 4.85), recovered from his recent illness, will start for the Giants’ season closing game tomorrow, Sunday, at 12:05. He’ll be opposed by Bobby Miller (11-5, 3.89)

Giants open final series of the season with a loss against the Dodgers 6-2

Photo courtesy of Los Angeles Dodgers X. Brusdar Graterol celebrates closing out the victory against the Giants on September 29, 2023.

By Titus Wilkinson (@TitusWisme)

SAN FRANCISCO- The Giants opened up their final series of the season against their rival the Dodgers with a loss by a final of 6-2.

The game-time weather was a little overcast with wind at 15 mph out to CF.

Before the game began Thairo Estrada was named the Willie Mac Award winner as voted on by teammates, coaches, trainers, and fans.

Thairo Estrada salutes the crowd as he accepts the Willie Mac Award at Oracle Park on September 29, 2023.

With Gabe Kapler fired earlier today Kai Correa took over as the interim manager. Correa became the youngest manager in the San Francisco era at 35 years old. The moment was also historic as both Correa and Roberts are of Asian descent which is the first time that two head coaches have faced each other in the four major sports leagues.

Keaton Winn got the nod to throw out the first pitch in this one as the Dodgers countered with veteran Lance Lynn. It was Winn’s ninth game of the season with him coming into this one sporting a 1-2 record and a 3.89 era.

Last game the Giants got a great start from Sean Manea who struck out eight while only giving up two runs in six innings.

Winn’s night on the mound would be haunted by the long ball as he gave up three home runs. The top of the order did most of the damage as Will Smith, Freddie Freeman, and J.D. Martinez got the three homers.

After a little bit of a bumpy start, Lynn steadied the ship going six innings and only allowing two earned runs. Those two runs he did give up both came from Wilmer Flores. In the first Flores got an RBI single and then got a solo home run in the third bringing his home run total up to 23 on the season.

In relief, Sean Hjelle had a solid outing as he gave up no runs and struck out four in 3.2 innings.

There were two batters hit by pitches tonight both Dodgers one of them Miguel Rojas was taken out of the game as he was hit on his left arm.

Freeman was not only of note due to his home run but he also got a single and a double. The double was his 59th of the season. While on the Giant’s side of things, Flores had another great night going 2-2 with an RBI and drawing a walk.

Lynn was credited with the win improving his record to 13-11. While Keaton Winn took the loss making his record now 1-3.

“I don’t play the game to get trophies or get any special recognition but obviously when you think about it now that my coaches and my teammates have voted for me it obviously means a lot,” Thairo Estrada said after the game.

The Giants will play game two of this final series of the season tomorrow at 6:05.

Giants fire Gabe Kapler after four seasons

San Francisco Giants manager Gabe Kapler walks to the dugout after making a pitching change during the seventh inning against the San Diego Padres at Oracle Park in San Francisco on Thu Sep 29, 2023. Which turned out to Kapler’s last game as a Giants manager. (AP News photo)

By Mary Anne

The San Francisco Giants fired their manager Gabe Kapler, also known as Kap, after four seasons with the team from 2020-23. Kapler led the Giants to one postseason trip in 2021 when they lost to their biggest rival, the Los Angeles Dodgers, in five games in the 2021 National League Division Series (NLDS). The Giants finished 107-55 in 162 regular-season games with a .660% win percentage in ’21.

Kapler previously served as manager of the Philadelphia Phillies from 2018-19. As an MLB shortstop, Kapler played for the Detroit Tigers (1998-99), Texas Rangers (2000-02), Colorado Rockies (2002-03), Boston Red Sox (2003-04, 2005-06), Yomiuri Giants (2005), Milwaukee Brewers (2008), and Tampa Bay Rays (2009-2010). And, as a NCAA baseball player, Kapler played for Cal State Fullerton before transferring to Moorpark College. Kapler was inducted into the Moorpark College Athletic Hall of Fame in 2008.

The Giants’ firing of Kapler, a 48-year-old Reseda, Los Angeles, California, native, came with just three regular-season games in 2023. The Giants’ record is 78-81, pending the final score of tonight’s home game against the Dodgers, who are 98-61 at present.

In a statement released to ESPN, Giants president of baseball operations Farhan Zaidi said he made the “recommendation to ownership” to fire Kapler and then did so after “receiving their approval.”

Kai Correa will serve as interim manager for the Giants’ last three games. Correa, an infield and baserunning coach, has been with the Giants since 2020. The 35-year-old is a Hilo, Hawaii, native of Native Hawaiian, Portuguese, and Japanese descent. Correa’s alma mater is the University of Puget Sound, where he played NCAA baseball and graduated with a degree in U.S. history.

Correa previously served as an infield coach and a defensive coordinator for the Cleveland Indians, a volunteer assistant and assistant coach for the University of Northern Colorado, and head assistant coach, recruiting coordinator, infield coach, and third-base coach for the University of Puget Sound.

That’s Amaury News and Commentary: Adiós Kapler!~ -Kai Correa named SF interim manager; Giants dismiss Kapler as manager with three games left in the season

The San Francisco Giants named Kai Correa as interim manager after firing Gabe Kapler on Thu Sep 29, 2023 (file photo USA Today)

Adiós Kapler!~ -Giants dismiss manager with three games left in the season

That’s Amaury News and Commentary

By Amaury Pi-González

SAN FRANCISCO–Gabe Kapler was never that popular when the Giants first signed him in 2020 and today became the first Giants manager to be fired since in September of 1995 when Jim Davenport was fired and replaced by Roger Craig.

In 2021 the Giants overachieved and won 107 games, and Gabe Kapler won the NL Manager of the Year. After two years as skipper of the Philadelphia Phillies, 2023 was the fourth season for Kapler.

Soon after noon on September 29, the San Francisco Giants released this statement: “He has been dedicated and passionate in his efforts to improve the on-field performance of the San Francisco Giants and I have tremendous respect for him as a colleague and friend” said team president Farhan Zaidi. Kapler’s first season with San Francisco was the pandemic-shortened 2020 campaign”

Names already rumored to be possible candidates for Giants manager in 2024, Menlo Park native and three-time Manager of the Year Bob Melvin, ending his first season as manager of the San Diego Padres, also Oakland A’s manager Mark Kotsay. But it is “too early” to tell.

Meanwhile, Giants veteran shortstop and three-time World Champion Brandon Crawford 36, said he likes to retire as a Giant, but he still contemplating his future and was not ready to commit to anything just yet. Crawford made the statement just a few days ago, on September 21. About the speculation if he is going to play his last game as a Giant and retire this next Sunday when the team closes the season against the LA Dodgers, he said: “I don’t have an answer, but there’s been plenty of thoughts”.

San Francisco closes the season at home this weekend with a three-game series against the Western Division champion Los Angeles Dodgers.

Loss in Giants clubhouse and post season could spell Zaidi and Kapler’s demise; Could Wotus be next in line for manager’s job?

San Francisco Giants special assistant and former third base coach Ron Wotus could possibly be in line for the Giants manager job. (AP file photo)

By Barbara Mason

San Francisco Giants team president Farhan Zaidi was asked by the Giants flagship station KNBR on Thursday did he see manager Gabe Kapler returning next season. Zaidi gave a non answer saying he appreciated that Giants owner Greg Johnson gave assurances that both Kapler and Zaidi would be returning for the 2024 season.

Zaidi talked about Kapler losing the clubhouse saying culturally when things are going right this group loves being together, they’re having fun. “But when you’re not doing well those things can be seen in a negative light,” he said.

On Monday night the Giants returned to Oracle Park taking on the San Diego Padres in a three game series. San Francisco pitcher Logan Webb had a sound outing winning 2-1. Instead of patting himself on the back for a fine outing when it was mentioned that he could be a NL Cy Young Award winner Webb gave credit to his opposing pitcher the Padres Blake Snell. He said that Snell should be the Cy Young Award winner and that he pitched a fine game.

Webb added that it’s not fun anymore. He said that the joy and fun just isn’t there right now. The Giants on Wednesday night lost after going into the top of the tenth inning with a 2-2 tie but saw three runs score for San Diego on a throwing error allowing a run and a two RBI base hit. There seems to be some malcontent in the locker room.

It was the quickest exit by the fans after the Padres scored the last two runs that had been seen at Oracle Park in a long time. The culture that Zaidi was talking about is just about all but gone. The Giants at one time had a shot at getting a Wild Card spot but went 2-8 on the previous road trip losing two out of three in Colorado, swept in two games in Arizona, and losing three out of four in Los Angeles.

The Giants really needed those wins on that road trip but it got away from them. The clubhouse after that road trip was strained at best. Kapler was stoic when answering questions at his post game meeting with the press after Wednesday night’s loss to the Padres.

When the Giants bombed on that last road trip Webb spoke up about the clubhouse mood. Then they lost two out of three to the Padres at Oracle and that mood was even more strained than on this last road trip. Johnson who seemed to be assured that Zaidi and Kapler would be back next season puts that statement in doubt.

Ironically special assistant coach Ron Wotus whose been with the Giants through four managers, Dusty Baker, Felipe Alou, Bruce Bochy and now Kapler could be a successor as manager if Kapler were to be fired. It was reported when Wotus spoke to the clubhouse all the players gave him their attention.

Webb questioned, “Why would you get to this position and not give it your best? Give it your all. I think it’s a great message, right. Because no matter what happens at the end of the year, we’re just going to go right back to the offseason and show up in spring training,” he said. He also believes that the team will do their best to try to get back into a possible post-season scenario much like the one they just blew in 2023.

Barbara Mason covers Giants baseball on the road for http://www.sportsradioservice.com

Giants Finish the 2023 Season, Hobbling Across the Finish Line Amid Season Disappointment

San Francisco Giants’ Brandon Crawford (35) celebrates in the dugout after scoring off of a single hit by Joc Pederson during the third inning on Tue Aug 8, 2023 against the Los Angeles Angels at the Big A in Anaheim. Crawford could be playing his last game of his career or with the Giants after Sun Oct 1, 2023 at Oracle Park vs. the Los Angeles Dodgers. (AP file photo)

By Barbara Mason

The 2023 MLB season is coming to an end with three games left for the San Francisco Giants (78-81). It has sure been a roller coaster ride for the team. The Giants that trailed the Dodgers by a single game at one time not too long ago is now three games below .500.

There was a time after the all-star break that this team was playing great baseball. They were winning so many different way and had a real knack for coming from behind and winning. That all came to a screeching halt in the past several months with the Giants getting really inconsistent.

When it looked like they were getting back on track, they would simply implode. It just seemed to fall to pieces. Some of the errors that came out of this dugout were crazy, errors that you just do not see everyday. The Giants have to be feeling a real sense of disappointment; coming so close and falling just short.

Thursday the Giants had their last day off before they take on the Los Angeles Dodgers in the final three-game series of the regular season at Oracle Park. The Dodgers will be off to the playoffs and the Giants will be off to parts unknown.

It will surely be a long off-season for San Francisco suffering yet another disappointing season. The Giants has quite a list of pending free agents which include Brandon Crawford who has not yet indicated if he will retire. There will for certain be some big changes considering how this season went. A younger and faster roster would be a good place to start. 22 players are over the age of 25 and 14 of them are 30 and older.

Friday night the Dodger series will get underway with first pitch scheduled for 7:15 PM. Keaton Winn will take the mound for the Giants with a 0-0, 3.89 ERA. For the Dodgers it will be Lance Lynn that the San Francisco offense will be facing. Lynn has a 12-11 win/loss record and a 5.83 ERA.

Mookie Betts and Freddie Freeman will be leading the offensive charge for Los Angles. San Francisco will be leaning on Wilmer Flores, Thairo Estrada and J.D. Davis in this final series. These final three games mean little to either team.

The Dodgers have locked in the No. 2 seed in the National League after having a tremendous 2023 regular season. They will open the division series at Dodger Stadium next Saturday. This season really went down to the wire for many of these teams and unfortunately San Francisco could not seal the deal.

It will likely be a quiet series this weekend although this is an age-old rivalry that may bring out fans rooting for both sides. It will be a farewell to the 2023 season for the San Francisco Giants missing yet another post season.

It will be an interesting and important off-season for the Giants as they make some roster changes that may be significant. Only time will tell what this team will look like as they head into the 2024 season.

Barbara Mason is an Oakland A’s podcast and beat writer at http://www.sportsradioservice.com

Flood gates open defense coughs up 3 runs in 10th as Pads defeat Giants 5-2

San Diego Padres’ Trent Grisham, left, runs toward Fernando Tatis Jr. (23) after scoring against the San Francisco Giants during the 10th inning at Oracle Park in San Francisco on Wed Sep 27, 2023 (AP News photo)

San Diego (79-80). 000 010 100 3. – 5. 10. 0

San Francisco (78-81). 010 100 000 0. – 2. 5. 3. 10 innings

Time: 2:52

Attendance: 32,151

By Lewis Rubman

SAN FRANCISCO—For Sean Manaea, the past may be the future. The veteran of eight years in the show, Manaea once was a mainstay of the A’s starting rotation; he no hit the powerful Red Sox in 20018, arguably his best season with Oakland, when he went 12-9, 3.59.

Traded to the Padres for the ’22 season, he was pretty much of a bust, going 7-8, 4.96. The Giants signed him as a free agent this year, and he was relegated to the bullpen and didn’t return to the rotation until September 12.

Manaea shut the Dodgers out on three over seven innings in his last outing and came to work tonight with an ERA of 2.00 in his three starts, which is in stark contrast to his overall mark of 7-6, 4.51. His fine performance didn’t prevent the Giants from falling apart in the tenth inning and losing, 5-2, to Manaea’s previous employers, the San Diego Padres.

Manaea completed his 1,000th inning as a big leaguer when he got Matthew Batten to pop out to first to end the fourth frame. In all, he hurled 6 + frames tonight, allowing only one run in the six but another in the plus. Both runs were earned, one coming on a home run.

Manaea faced 24 batters and threw them exactly 100 pitches, 67 for strike. He allowed seven hits and didn’t issue any walks. It was a satisfying performance, but Manaea had to settle for a no decision that reduced his ERA to 4.44.

The left handed veteran Manaea was opposed by the right handed rookie Matt Waldron, making his sixth major league start out of eight appearances. He was 1-3, 4.58. His ERA as a starter was 4.91; it’s 3.72 pitching out of the pen. Waldron also produced a credible performance. Over six innings he held the Giants to two runs on five hits and two walks. One of the hits was a four bagger.

Manaea threw 82 pitches, 54 for strikes. He, too, had to settle for a no decision and reduced his earned run average, which now stands at 4.35. Seth Barlow replaced him on the mound after the crowd of 32,151 had finished singing “Take Me Out to the Ball Game.”

Thairo Estrada’s solo home run in the home second, his 14th round tripper of the season, put San Francisco ahead, 1-0. The 418 foot blast to left center came on a 73.9 mph knuckle ball that sailed off the Giants’ second baseman’s bat at 102 mph. The knuckler is Waldron’s favorite pitch; he throws it 27.2% of the time.

The Friars tied the score in the top of the fifth with a leadoff double by José Azocar, followed by a nubber in front of the plate that went as a single to Brett Sullivan and sent Azocar to third, from which he came home on Bogaerts’ sac fly to center.

The Giants came charging back in the bottom of the third with Michael Conforto’s leadoff double against the National Car Rental advertisement in left center field. With two outs, they foiled The Cure on Tyler Fitzgerald’s pop single to shallow right, and the orange and black was (were?) back in the lead, 2-1.

But not for long.Garrett Cooper ended Manaea’s night’s work with his 17th home run of the year, a leadoff blast that cleared the same National Car Rental ad against which Conforto had hit his two bagger. Ryan Walker entered the game as Manaea left to warm applause. Walker lived up to his name and allowed a walk and hit a batter, but that was all.

The submariner Tyler Rogers. set his ex teammates down in order in the eighth helped by Flores’s wonderful backhand stop and off balance throw to first on Machado’s bouncing ball down the third base line to end the inning.

Roberto Suárez kept it tied with a scoreless eighth.

The top of the ninth brought Camilo Doval to the mound for the home team. Kim, the first Padre he faced, lifted a foul fly to right on which Yastrzemski made a beautiful tumbling rollover catch for the first out. Cooper lined a double down the third base line.

Jurickson Profar pinch hit for Batten, and Eddie Roario was inserted as a pinch runner for Cooper. Doval fanned Profar, bringing Trent Grisham to the plate as a pinch hitter for Azocar. Doval got him out on a tricky bouncer to Estrada.

Josh Harder, who had earned the save in last night’s battle, walked Marco Luciano on four pitches to start the Giants’ ninth. Bailey, batting right handed — his strong side — for the first time tonight, struck out swinging, also went down swinging. Austin Slater pinch hit for Wade and forced Luciano out at second, 6-5, sending us into extra innings.

John Brebbia, yesterday’s unexpected opener, replaced Doval on the bump for the top of the 20th. He retired Bret Sullivan on a grounder to short, but zombie runner Grisham advanced to the third on the play and scored on Bogaerts’ sac fly to right. Tatís reached first on Luciano’s throwing error, and the Giants conceded a walk to Soto that put Tatís on second.

With Machado at bat, Bailey tried to pick Tatís off and threw the ball into center field, allowing both runners to advance a base. Both of them scored when the Manny you love to hate dumped a Texas League single into center.

Tom Cosgrove was chosen to protect the friars’ 5-2 lead in the bottom of the frame. Luis Matos pinch hit for Yaz and grounded out to short. Slater had to hold on at second, where he again had to remain when Flores bounced out to third. Héliot Ramos pinch hit for Pederson and grounded out to short to end the misery.

Brebbia, now 3-4, 3.55, was charged with the loss, even though a less porous defence might have resulted in him getting the win. Hader, the pitcher of record when the Padres forged ahead, got the win, making him 2-3, 1.16. Cosgrove got the save, his first.

The Giants will have a day off tomorrow to lick their wounds. They’ll play host to the Dodgers on Friday. No pitchers have been announced.

San Francisco Giants podcast with Stephen Ruderman: Webb says losing not fun, not enjoyable; Does CEO Larry Baer share in the blame?

San Francisco Giants pitcher Logan Webb works against the San Diego Padres during the first inning at Oracle Park in San Francisco on Tue Sep 26, 2023 (AP News photo)

On the San Francisco Giants podcast with Stephen Ruderman:

#1 San Francisco Giants pitcher Logan Webb who did win his last game last Monday night said after the game that he was tired of losing despite winning the game and gave praise to San Diego pitcher Blake Snell who opposed him saying he was the one who deserved the Cy Young Award. Webb also added he was tired of losing as the Giants once again will not be a post season team.

#2 Webb said that Alex Cobb pitched good enough all season long and was an All Star this season and it was a shame that someone like that didn’t make post season after all the work he put into the season.

#3 You had mentioned this on your last Giants podcast why would any free agent want to sign with the Giants? Is it the environment, is it that manager Gabe Kapler and team president Farhan Zaidi have trouble making thing work amongst deals and certain strategies on the field.

#4 Does the problems go to the top with team CEO Larry Baer how much does he bare some of the brunt of the blame because he’s watching how much he spends on getting talent or is there some belt tightening involved?

#5 Baer said that the attendance would surge but the Giants are 17th in attendance. Some critics say Baer inherited two World Champion teams from former team CEO Bill Neukom and once those teams dissolved the Giants made the post season just once?

Stephen Ruderman is filling in for Michael Duca on the Giants podcasts at http://www.sportsradioservice.com