Sharks Putting Pieces Together

By Mary Walsh

Training camp is well under way for the San Jose Sharks. Some players are getting a shot to make the team, others have a guaranteed spot but have to move on from an offseason that was too long. The way last season ended should not be forgotten, but Sharks players, coaches and staff have to forgive themselves and each other, and move forward. That will involve some mental acrobatics that will last well beyond training camp and into the season.

Justin Braun’s five year contract extension is an excellent step ahead. With Braun under contract through the 2019-20 season, the Sharks have secured yet another talented and still improving young defenseman. From the Sharks’ press release:

“Justin has emerged as one of our most well-rounded and dependable defensemen,” said Wilson. “He’s an excellent skater who excels in matching up against the opponents top players on a nightly basis and fits in well with our core group of younger players. We feel Justin has just scratched the surface of his talent and we are excited to have him under contract for the next six seasons.”

Last season, Braun was second on the team in average time on ice per game (20:59), tied-for-first in shorthanded ice time per game (2:11) and set career-highs for points (17), goals (4) and assists (13). He was one of four Sharks to play in all 82 games in 2014-15. In addition, he tied a franchise record with eight blocked shots on Nov. 29 vs. St. Louis.

Braun also added two points (one goal, one assist) in seven Stanley Cup Playoff games.

It is clear that Braun has been doing the job the Sharks need him to do, logging a lot of minutes in pressure situations. There is little doubt that he can be expected to continue doing this for the team. In his first season with the team, he seemed a little more eager offensively. That is something he may build on now that he has garnered the “dependable” label usually reserved for more seasoned veterans.

What the press release does not brag about is how salary cap friendly the deal is for the Sharks. Starting in 2015, Braun’s cap hit is just $3.8 million, a modest number for a defenseman the team plans to depend on for so many years. Five years is a long time of course, the risk of injury always looms. But it is a risk the team was wise to take. Braun is a smart, cool-headed player. He is much more likely to improve than regress over the next few seasons.

Speaking of the salary cap, how unfamiliar is it for the Sharks to still be so far down CapGeek’s list (at 21 today)? They have $6,145,000 available, with 23 players signed and the stated intention of not shopping for help. It is an unfamiliar situation to not be in the top five list of teams that have no money to spend.

The hot topic at the start of camp was still who was not wearing a letter on their sweater. At this point, I am willing to examine the decision to remove the letters from Joe Thornton and Patrick Marleau less as an indictment of those two and more as a challenge to the rest of the team.

The idea that there are more than three or four leaders in the room is not a new one. It is something players have said over and over on many teams. But what does it really mean? If you take away the title of captain, everyone has to look a little harder at everyone in the room and ask themselves who they would like to hear from, who they should be listening to. So long as someone wears the letter, there must be some expectation that that guy will start the conversation if it needs to be started.

The decision to have a team meeting in Tahoe before camp came from Adam Burish and Jason Demers. Both are known for being engaging and media friendly, good ambassadors, but neither has worn a letter on the team. Perhaps this is a sign that different players, more players, are warming up to the idea of leading with or without a letter. Or maybe those two would have come up with that idea no matter what the state of designated leadership was. In any case, it is an example of what can occur when leadership roles are up for grabs.

In that sense, it may be regrettable that a team needs to put letters on anyone at all for games. To switch them around frequently could cause confusion during games. To put them on will quell the useful chaos that a lack of letters can produce.

While the captaincy question may produce some positive chemistry for the team, it is hard to ignore the way the decision was initially communicated- or not- to the players involved. That still makes it seem like a reprimand to Thornton and Marleau as well as the rest of the team. Of course if everyone is responsible, then that includes them.

NHL: New Rules 2014-15

By Mary Walsh

Many of the rule changes announced by the NHL this week could improve player safety. A couple of changes are unrelated to safety but could improve fairness. Others look like half-measures and one seems entirely nonsensical.

The changes around the face off dot will certainly have the most immediate impact. Putting more distance between the players taking a faceoff will make even the most skilled NHL center adjust his routine. The only advantage would be to players transitioning from international leagues, since the new 5’7″ distance matches international rules.

That change has not been confirmed yet, so players can’t properly prepare for it until the season starts. The new hash marks will be tested in preseason before a decision is made. It could cause some ice surface problems if the changes is not made and everyone has to repaint at the last minute.

The change to the tripping rule is the one I find the most symbolically significant. Those heroic last-ditch efforts where a player dives for the puck after he loses the race? That extreme no-quit stretch and slide? No more will those be forgiven. Instead they will be called a minor penalty, and in some cases cause for a penalty shot.

Like some of the other changes, the tripping rule change gives officials greater latitude to penalize dangerous plays. Rule 23 has been expanded to include elbowing, clipping, kneeing, and other physical fouls. Where Rule 23 game misconducts used to apply only to hits from behind and boarding, almost anything that is likely to cause a head injury can now be penalized under Rule 23. If applied properly, this may reduce serious injuries, but as with all rules, the proper application is a big if.

To counter abuse of these safety rules, the NHL has increased penalties and fines for embellishment. The fines increase according to the number of recorded infractions. The first infraction gets a warning, the next a $2000 fine, up to the fifth through eight infractions which each merit a $5000 fine. The fourth infraction introduces a fine for the head coach as well as the player, and these fines keep going up to the eighth.

One rule change eliminates some penalties. The change to the out of bounds rule means that-in some cases- a team will not be pushed out of the attacking zone even if they caused the puck to go out of bounds. The situations listed that allow the faceoff to remain in the attack zone include flukey situations like broken glass, pucks off the side of the net and pucks wedged under the net. The list also includes pretty common situations like pucks deflecting out of play off the boards, the glass, or even a teammate. Short of an attacking player shooting the puck right over the glass, it looks like a team will rarely lose ground for putting the puck out of play while in the offensive zone.

The goalkeeper’s restricted area has been increased so that it now looks more like a rectangle that a trapezoid. If you pretend it is a rectangle, you could say the trapezoid has been eliminated, without eliminating the limits on where the goalie is allowed to play the puck. The new area does give the goalie two additional feet on either side of the goal posts. This will provide more options for goalies to play the puck, so that is something.

The change to rule 24, banning spin-o-rama moves in penalty shots and shootouts seems petty. Where many of the 2014 rule changes can be said to improve player safety, this change does nothing but eliminate the occasionally silly spin move. Most spin-o-ramas fail anyway, it seemed unnecessary for the NHL to remove a sometimes entertaining shot option.

Sharks Camp Schedule Released

By Mary Walsh

The long quiet season is coming to a close as 2014-15 NHL training camps are announced. The Sharks roster remains status quo. Some players have started  skating at Sharks Ice, though obviously these skates are not called Captain’s Skates since there is no team captain.

The San Jose Sharks officially announced their camp schedules this week. All practices will be at Sharks Ice in San Jose.

The team also announced that individual tickets will go on sale on September 13 at 10:00 am. They will be available from Ticketmaster and at the SAP Center box office.

The Sharks Fan Fest is scheduled for September 27, prior to the 5:00 preseason game against the Ducks. Per the press release, activities will include:

the rare chance to watch a Sharks practice at SAP Center, an opportunity to take photos with the Shark Head on the ice, Sharks player and alumni autograph stations, and player, coach and alumni roundtable sessions on the Comcast SportsNet California and KFOX stages, moderated by the new Sharks broadcast team. In addition, arena concession stands will be open for food and beverage.

The event is sponsored by YP. Outside the SAP Center, music and carnival activities will be available before the game. The event is free of charge but you will need tickets. Reserve them at the Sharks website.

On Friday, September 12, the prospects will take the ice for the Rookie camp. The prospects will head to Anaheim the next day for Futures games on September 13 and 14.

The rest of the team will start camp on Friday, September 19. As usual, the team will be split into two squads and skate in two rinks. Detailed lists of which player will be in which squad will be released later. The teams will hold public scrimmages on Saturday the 20th and Sunday the 21st at 9:50 am.

The team will participate in four preseason home games, including a game at Stockton Arena, at 7:30 on September 23. The team will be split as they also have a game scheduled in Vancouver on that date.

The three other pre-season home games will take place at SAP Center in San Jose. They will be: September 26 (Coyotes, 7:30), September 27 (Ducks, 5:00) and September 30 (Kings, 7:30). The final pre-season games will be in Glendale on October 3 and Anaheim on October 4. Those games will be broadcast on KFOX at 7:00. Pregame shows “Sharks Warm-Up” and “The Coach’s Chalkboard” will be returning, starting with these two preseason road games.

Additional broadcast updates include some channel corrections. The April 3, 4 (Arizona), 6 (Dallas) and 9 (Edmonton) will be on ComCast Sportsnet California Plus instead of Comcast Sportsnet California. The April 11 game (Los Angeles) will be on NBC instead of NBCSN.

NHL: Young Sharks Moving Forward

By Mary Walsh

The Sharks announced that Jamie Baker will fill the open spot next to Randy Hahn on the television broadcast. Bret Hedican will step in to Baker’s spot next to Dan Rusanowsky on the radio broadcasts. The moves are consistent with the team’s minimalist approach to this off-season. Baker and Hedican are both familiar faces and voices to Sharks fans, their presence will not be a surprise to anyone. What might surprise viewers will be that, if they have a chance to catch an Edmonton Oilers broadcast, they will see Drew Remenda there. The announcements close out a quiet summer for the Sharks, if you ignore the ruckus over the John Scott signing. There is still time for the Sharks to do something surprising, but with September here, fans can look forward to preseasons games starting on September 23.

One of the stated goals of the San Jose Sharks this season is to allow their younger players to take a greater leadership than previously. That may be easier than it sounds, since the Sharks are younger than they have been in a long time. On the current roster, they only have seven skaters over 30, six forwards and one defenseman. They only have one player over 35, defenseman Scott Hannan. That looks promising when compared to the last two Stanley Cup champions, who had seven skaters over 30 (Los Angeles in 2013-14) and eight 30-somethings (Chicago in 2012-13) respectively. Giving youth a chance is certainly the trend in the NHL, though someone should tell that to the New Jersey Devils. They have nine forwards over 30, three over 35, and four defensemen over 30, with two over 35. Age might be a theme in stories about Sharks-Devils games this season.

Three Sharks prospects moved on this summer. Forward John McCarthy signed a one year contract with the St Louis Blues. 28 year old McCarthy was drafted in the seventh round by the Sharks in 2006 and played 87 games with San Jose over four seasons. The bulk of those games were played in the 2010-11 and 2013-14 seasons, in which he scored 3 goals and 3 points. He played five seasons with the AHL’s Worcester Sharks, serving as captain for one season and earning 133 points. He joins fellow Sharks alum Benn Ferriero, who also signed a one year contract with the St. Louis organization.

Defenseman Sena Acolatse signed a one year contract with the Calgary Flames. Acolatse played 156 games with the Worcester Sharks over three seasons. 23 year old Acolatse had 17 goals, 42 assists points and 217 penalty minutes with Worcester. He was the first Bay Area prospect signed by the Sharks. Ex-Shark Devin Setoguchi also signed a one-year contract for the upcoming season with Calgary.

Defenseman Nick Petrecki signed a one year AHL deal with the Rochester Americans. The 25 year old played five seasons with the Worcester Sharks, earning 46 points. He was ranked second in franchise history for penalty minutes (531) (Frazer McLaren had 577) and first in games played with 277. He was drafted in the first round in 2007 by the Sharks and played one game with San Jose in 2012-13. He joined the Rochester Americans at the end of last season, played 14 games with them and five playoff games.

Tracking other ex-Sharks, goaltender Evgeni Nabakov will be with the Tampa Bay Lightning this season. Thomas Greiss has signed a one year contract with the Pittsburgh Penguins. Dany Heatley will be seen often by Sharks fans, now as a member of the Anaheim Ducks. TJ Galiardi swapped places with Devin Setoguchi, moving from Calgary to Winnipeg. Manny Malthotra signed a one year contract with Montreal, and Daniel Winnik signed with Toronto.

Sharks Need to Get Stories Straight

By Mary Walsh

The way the San Jose Sharks have proceeded this summer has been heavy on theory and light on specifics. Their plan has been revealed primarily through  inaction and subtraction. “Giving more responsibility to young players,” for example, sounds like a great idea, but removing the C and the A from Joe Thornton and Patrick Marleau is the first specific step the team has taken in that direction. They also removed some veterans, letting Dan Boyle walk, and buying out Martin Havlat. Beyond that, Doug Wilson has left his plan wide open for interpretation. For those of us who like to think the team will take another run at the playoffs fueled mostly by the angry memory of recent failure, there is fodder enough to think that. But that same fodder, the minimal roster and staff changes, could be used to argue pretty much anything or nothing at all.

The Sharks’ captaincy is the more glitzy story, but the Raffi Torres knee surgery mess is at least as significant. In neither case are the specifics that momentous. Hockey players get hurt and sidelined all the time, and the knee should be a long way from a life-altering injury. The importance of who wears which letter is of debatable importance, but both stories red-flag communication problems with the Sharks.

One hint that information does not flow well in San Jose is the apparently catastrophic state of Raffi Torres’ knee. Why Torres had to have his knee repaired a second time due to an infection resulting from a procedure known to be highly susceptible to infections… well that is a saga that boggles the mind. Knee surgeries are supposed to be straight forward, more commonly complicated by things like advanced age. The Sharks have had too many problems with player knee surgeries to ignore the stink. It is enormously disappointing that there is no return date for Torres. In the few games he has played with the Sharks, he has been very much a difference maker, and not for the reasons his dubious reputation would suggest. When playing with discipline, he is exactly what the Sharks need right now: a middle-six winger with all the tools to score and create scoring chances. All of that is moot now, as he is out indefinitely.

The fiasco around who knew what when regarding the letters suggests that the Sharks will need more than new software to fix communication problems. Coach Todd McLellan accepted blame for not being clear in a meeting with Joe Thornton and Patrick Marleau. That lack of clarity resulted in Thornton not being aware of the decision until asked by reporters. Sometimes being clear is only a matter of saying exactly what you mean. Euphemisms and metaphors are nice but people really do need to know what you are doing as well as why you are doing it.

It is easy to see why the phrase “clean slate” would not necessarily mean “we are stripping you of your letters to start training camp.”  In such an environment, McLellan should know that he has to spell things out, especially to his players. It is better to be accused of tedious repetition than of vagueness.

In an interview with TSN last week, Larry Robinson suggested that Joe Thornton might not have been as approachable as a captain needs to be. That came as a surprise to me, not because Thornton is such a jovial fellow with the media. The easy-going style the cameras are used to would not be very effective at motivating his team, so one could only hope Thornton shows a more assertive persona to his team-mates. Yet Robinson suggested the opposite, that Thornton maybe needed to have a softer touch to be a successful captain.

Obviously, leadership methods have evolved a lot since the Middle Ages, where a club served as well as courtesy, but even Machiavelli knew that subtle manipulation often worked better than mass terror. Certainly a hockey team captain should be available to listen to his teammates, but his teammates have to be willing to speak as well. Even if Thornton lacks the mastery to encourage a taciturn person to speak, I don’t buy that the Sharks are a particularly timid lot. I think it is misguided to put communication failures on any particular player.

Sharks media coverage misses Ryane Clowe, we will miss Dan Boyle. They were two of the more outspoken players in public. Were they also the most outspoken in team meetings? Few NHL players share as much as they did, few were as emotive in post game interviews. (Raffi Torres can be a good interview. Too bad his availability has been and will be so limited by injury.)

Is there really such a large gap between what we see in front of the cameras and what goes on off camera? Are the Sharks too careful with their words to get the job done? Will deposing the captain make a difference? Do players defer to a letter or to reputation and status? If longtime Sharks defer to players like Thornton and Marleau out of habit, then new arrivals will be hard pressed to do anything else.

It will take more than putting letters up for grabs to get this team talking. It might sound silly, but maybe they need to get a talking stick and pass it around at every meeting. Nothing could be sillier than a group of grown men unwilling to air their thoughts, good or bad, with a team they are supposed to be part of. They certainly need to do something to get in the habit of saying whatever is on their minds, before it festers and scuttles another season.

NHL: The All-Important Details

By Mary Walsh

From the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge to the NHL’s new Terms of Service agreement, the trick this week has been to sort through volumes of information to find the relevant details.

The ALS Ice Bucket Challenge is certainly the more widely compelling story. It began as an awareness campaign for ALS (aka Lou Gehrig’s Disease) and has spread far and wide. It seems that anyone with a recognizable face or name is fair game for a challenge. In the NHL, the names of hockey players, management, owners, league executives and journalists have all popped up with videos and photos of dousings accompanied by challenges to others to get doused.

Beyond hockey, you can also find Hollywood celebrities posting their videos and challenging each other. Of course you don’t have to be a celebrity to participate, but your tweets and videos will probably get more views. The primary platforms for the challenges are also the most used social network sites: Twitter and Facebook. This is where the details come in. At least one person familiar to Sharks fans challenged someone who had already been challenged:

Actually, joining Twitter would not be enough for Drew Remenda to know who exactly had been challenged. There are so many people involved now that you would have to join and read Twitter for several hours a day to keep track. Even a standard Twitter search only gives you a sampling. Many videos are being posted without a helpful hashtag.

That is excellent news for ALS research. Awareness campaigns take some criticism for creating more noise than progress, but this campaign at least has paid some dividends for the cause. In the first couple weeks of the campaign, the ALS Association received $1.25 million in donations, an enormous jump for the same time period last year. While the challenge does have a donation in lieu of dousing component, it is unlikely that most of that money came from people who preferred not to have a bucket of ice water dumped on them. Even if it did not start out as a fund raiser, the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge has done an excellent job of raising both awareness and money for a good cause.

It is worth noting that some of the long-term symptoms of brain damage are similar to ALS. Until relatively recently, many people were diagnosed with ALS when in fact they were suffering the long-term results of concussions. While symptoms are similar, the causes are quite different. There is no reason to suppose that this is why the hockey community has supported the cause so enthusiastically, but it is an interesting connection that predates one awareness campaign.

A more hockey-specific bit of news also cropped up this week, with the NHL’s revised Terms of Service Agreement. A section was added explaining that users could not mine NHL sites without permission, either manually or with automated data gathering programs. Not long ago, this little passage might have been considered irrelevant small print. At the moment, it can probably still be regarded as such by most users, but it could pose a problem very quickly for sites that sort and interpret NHL statistics. Sites like Behind the Net could be asked to stop using these stats without getting permission from the NHL. They could even be asked to pay for them.

It is true that this seems to be the Advanced Stats community’s coming out summer. NHL teams are hiring well-regarded hockey statisticians as quickly as Bleacher Report is hiring popular bloggers. Both moves are sensible business decisions, and probably long overdue. Did this acceptance of statistical analysis trigger the NHL’s sudden concern that they were giving their numbers away for free when they should not be?

Maybe the new TOS was overdue as well. Those statistics don’t compile themselves or even get to the website without many eyes and hands working to gather and publish them. Shouldn’t the advertising revenue from the site be enough to cover that? Maybe. Or maybe the recognition that stats are valuable means everyone will put more value on them, including monetary value. I would not say that the NHL is waging war on advanced stats sites, but they have put themselves in a position to claim their share of any value derived from those stats. 

The discussion is very similar to other cases involving Fair Use of copyrighted material. In short, if the use of someone else’s work is deemed “fair” it is okay, you don’t have to sell your house to pay the owner of the material you used. “Fair” use can include non-profit educational purposes, commentary on the material, or use that does no harm to the owner’s rights. The last part is mentioned in the NHL’s TOS, where they talk about harm:

You may not access or use, or attempt to access or use, the Services to take any action that could harm us or any other person or entity

That line covers more than ownership rights, implying that the NHL wants the option to defend against any sort of abuse using their material, but the Fair Use question is the simplest to identify and the most likely to be acted on first.

Fair Use has most conspicuously applied to music, books, and images. The owner of the material usually prevails in a law suit. There are a lot of people using images without permission, but that is only because many industries recognize the value of having their images promoted for free. (The music industry is notorious for their refusal to see it that way.) Even with images, though, you don’t have the right to use just any image any way you want. The same applies to data, so anyone who helps turn that data into a valuable commodity runs the risk that the owner might notice and ask to be compensated. The owners certainly played a part in making NHL statistics valuable, by making them available for free to so many for so long. Was this little take-back part of the plan from the start? Probably. You have to get people hooked before you can make any money as a data-dealer.

Sharks and Kings to Play Outdoors in Santa Clara

By Mary Walsh

Next season, Northern California will get its first outdoor NHL game. The Sharks will host the Kings on February 21, 2015, at Santa Clara’s brand spanking new Levi’s Stadium. From the Sharks’ press release:

“We are honored and elated that the NHL has selected the San Jose Sharks to participate in the NHL’s 2015 Coors Light Stadium Series and is bringing this magnificent event to the Bay Area,” said San Jose Sharks Chief Operating Officer John Tortora. “This event celebrates the growth of the great game of hockey in San Jose and recognizes the incredible support and passion of Sharks fans all over Northern California. We know our fans will bring the electrifying atmosphere of SAP Center at San Jose to Levi’s Stadium on Feb. 21 and we are looking forward to showcasing Sharks Territory outside and under the lights.”

That sounds grand, and it is very grand, enormous even. The Sharks deserve the attention. They have done a great deal to promote hockey in the Bay Area. On top of that, the size of the venue for outdoor games is a popular selling point, so it is important to have a big stadium. Levi’s has a rough capacity of 70,000. AT&T Park in San Francisco only has room for about 42,000.

Regardless of stadium size, I never thought it was likely that San Francisco would be the location. If there is any suitable competition for a big sporting event, they can usually beat San Francisco in a bidding war. San Francisco thinks too highly of itself to beg for anything. It bothers me that San Francisco doesn’t try harder to host the big parties. Heck, they couldn’t even hang on to their football team. Maybe San Francisco hates contact sports, so they send them to Santa Clara.

And yet… I remember meeting some travelers from Santa Clara and other South Bay cities. I met them here and there, overseas and even as near as the east coast. They had given up trying to tell people where they were from and started saying they were from near San Francisco or even claiming San Franciscanship. I had to press to discover the truth (my duty as a San Franciscan by birth), but they were happy I had heard of their towns. This is why San Francisco thinks it’s all that. No matter how many times it loses out to a less well-known neighbor, it still has the global name recognition that places like Santa Clara envy.

Don’t get me wrong, I like San Francisco. It is a pretty city, it has nice views, good food, liberal views, and interesting geography. But arrogance doesn’t look good on anyone.

Santa Clara is a good location for the outdoor game. It is right where Bay Area folks expect to find hockey. You can park in Santa Clara. Heck, you can hardly drive in SF anymore. Levi’s stadium has gotten great reviews, it will no doubt look good on television. Sharks fans should be glad the NHL didn’t put the game in Southern California. The way Southern California dominates the California hockey story is tedious.

Of course San Jose versus Los Angeles is a great matchup for its back story. Northern California and Southern California love to hate each other, almost as much as they love to bicker with other states.  The Sharks and the Kings have a lovely history of aggravating each other, though Los Angeles might not remember when San Jose was a legitimate threat to them. Even when they were down three games to none, the Kings did not seem worried. Perhaps worry is just not something they do in Los Angeles. By contrast, the over-use of black clothing and gloomy thoughts is still common up here. Or maybe that is just SF.

Of course there is still the possibility that there will be another outdoor game in Northern California, and that might be in San Francisco. San Francisco hockey fans can always hope.

NHL: Subban’s $9 M Deal Top Among Defensemen

By Mary Walsh

The San Jose Sharks did not make any news this week, apart from new social network software for the corporate offices. That story is kind of interesting in light of the “co-workers, not teammates” comments from come players after last season. Maybe I am reading too much into it. Meanwhile…

The NHL did have some big news, from the Montreal Canadiens and P.K. Subban. After meeting with an arbitrator, the team came to terms with their rising star to the tune of a $9 million cap hit for eight years.

Subban’s deal makes him the third highest paid player in the NHL, until the contracts of Jonathan Toews and Patrick Kane kick in in 2015. Of course by then there may be players being paid even more.

Subban’s actual salary changes from seven to eleven million through the contract, giving the Canadiens some flexibility in cap hit, though the contract is reported to have a no movement clause for all eight years. Evgeni Malkin also has a no movement clause for all eight years of his $9.5 million contract with the Pittsburgh Penguins, while Alex Ovechkin has a limited no trade clause in his 13 year $9.538 million contract.

The deal should come as no surprise considering how high profile and talented Subban is, yet the team went all the way to arbitration hearings before settling with their defenseman. Additionally, his last deal was also for just two years and the parties took a long time coming to it. Why the Canadiens are so unwilling to admit the importance of this player is baffling. Even as a rookie, all eyes were on him as a rising star. Every time his minutes were cut or he was scratched it made news.

For the past two seasons, he has been first and fifth in points among NHL defensemen. He was in the top 25 in his second and third seasons, if you count the first season when he only played two games. His rise up the charts has been unrelenting.  While high-scoring forwards make great press and television, NHL teams understandably value their top defensemen as longer term investments.  That the Canadiens seem to have had trouble coming to terms with theirs does not speak well for their management. Ultimately, dragging their feet does not appear to have saved them any money. They still have the highest paid defenseman in the league.

Has race been a factor? It has of course been, in terms of media visibility. No matter what goes on between player and team, race is always a question in today’s society. Ugly as that is, a player of color brings even more visibility to the team and the sport, which is a good thing in an entertainment field.

Subban himself does not seem bitter about the negotiations, but how can anyone be very bitter after getting a contract like that? Even if he were in doubt about how much the team valued him, or what the team’s prospects are, he is in an excellent position to control his future. A no movement clause only binds the team unless they want to buy him out. The player can always negotiate to be traded if it comes to that.

Is the Subban contract likely to set a precedent? All contracts set precedents, but only for comparable players. There are not many players who can claim to be comparable to Subban right now. Unless his performance takes a dive, his contract will not be a burden for Montreal. He is an enromously valuable asset. Will his performance dip? In such a young player, entering his sixth season in the NHL, it might be expected for a contract like this to cause a drop in intensity. Yet all signs point to Subban continuing on an upward trajectory. Intensity seems to come naturally for him.

NHL: “If They Can Take The Job…”

-By Mary Walsh

The San Jose Sharks did not make any moves this week, they did not even turn up in the rumor mill. For better or worse, it does look like Joe Thornton and Patrick Marleau be in teal next season. As I have said before, I think that is for the best.

Listening to a radio interview with the Red Wings’ Mike Babcock, I was reminded of Doug Wilson’s comments about the role he expects younger players to take this coming season.

Back in May, Wilson described part of his plan for the team. He was talking about Al Stalock’s chances of taking the starter’s role:

Every one of our young players will be given the chance to take whatever role they want. That includes him. When you go through this you have guys who are aching and begging for that opportunity. If they can come in and do it they can take it.

In an interview with Detroit Sports 105.1 on July 17, Mike Babcock said something very similar:

We’re gonna play the best players. So just like we did last year- it’s always a hard thing when a veteran on a one way contract doesn’t make the lineup, but that’s life- we’re committed to the growth of this team. Most franchises to get back on top have to get bad for ten years. That’s not our plan. We’ve scrounged to get in the playoffs the last two years in a row. I think we did a real good job, had a real good run against Chicago. I didn’t like us in the playoffs last year against Boston, but we like what we have coming. And we like our kids, so the biggest thing is not to rush them. We could really use some puck-moving D. Well we just happen to have some puck-moving D in the minors, big guys who can skate. When are they ready? We’re sure not going to rush them but if they’re capable of taking jobs they’re gettin’ the jobs.

There are some differences there, the focus on giving players time is something that Wilson has put less emphasis on lately. The last part, about giving the young players a chance to take jobs if they are capable, this sends up some red flags for me. My confusion stems from how you get from the first sentence (“We’re gonna play the best players.”) to the last one (“We’re sure not going to rush them but if they’re capable of taking jobs they’re gettin’ the jobs.”).

If these guys are the best players you have, why in the world would they NOT, under any and all circumstances, get the job?

Maybe I am misreading the “taking jobs” part. Do they simply mean “if they are capable of doing the job, since we don’t have anyone better, we will let them play instead of going out and finding someone older”? Shouldn’t they also mean “if they are better than the older players we have, we will use them”? Shouldn’t they always mean that?

It certainly seems like the Sharks have not followed that last rule. Yes, Matt Irwin lacked experience, but all signs pointed to him being a better option in many games last season than Brad Stuart or Scott Hannan. Given the ice time to develop his game, won’t he be a quicker, higher return asset than those two were last season? If he doesn’t play he won’t develop, but that is true of any young player. The team followed the same pattern with Marc-Edouard Vlasic and Justin Braun and to a lesser extent Jason Demers: using older veterans again and again while the young players seemed ready and in need of ice time.

This notion that a younger player with more upside will be benched to let a veteran play is insane. Yes, the veteran might represent a lower short-term risk but if a younger player is capable of taking the job, doesn’t that mean he is not a higher risk long term? Doesn’t that mean he is capable of taking the job from the veteran? To say a younger player will get to play if he is capable of taking the job sounds like the team had previously given far to much consideration to veteran status. This is not just a matter of fairness and meritocracy, it is the difference between winning and losing.

On the other hand, it can be risky to put too much on a younger player. Eric Gilmore published a piece on NHL.com suggesting that Mirco Mueller could crack the Sharks lineup this coming season. Doug Wilson has suggested as much in the past. Tomas Hertl cracked the lineup last season, in his first year in North America. Couldn’t Mueller make the big club early too? Other defensemen have done it but comparing Hertl’s role to Mueller’s is clearly comparing apples to oranges. A defenseman’s job is much more complicated, traditionally defensemen take longer to develop their professional game. To move any player up to the NHL too soon can have a negative impact on his game, and with defensemen that impact can be that much worse.

So, as eager as fans might be to see Mueller make the jump, it seems unlikely that such a move would be a good thing for the Sharks or Mueller.

It might just be noise. Hannan is returning, Thornton and Marleau very probably are too. The team will have no shortage of veterans to fall back on. If their humiliation as group at the end of last season stung them as much as they claim, less roster turnover is better than more.

Sharks Keep Demers and Doherty in the Fold

By Mary Walsh

Tuesday, the San Jose Sharks announced the resigning of defensemen Jason Demers and Taylor Doherty. The team gave Demers a two year contract and Doherty one year. The moves solidified the team’s current blue line and add some depth for the future. It might not be enough to improve their offseason PuckDaddy grade from an F, but it is a start.

Last season was a bounce-back season for Demers, who performed below expectations the two seasons prior. Those seasons were marred by injury but also found him often benched as a healthy scratch. His improvement this past season could be attributed to better health and the changes on the coaching staff that occurred before the last lockout season. All of the team’s young defensemen have shown improvement since Larry Robinson and Jim Johnson joined the team.

Demers’ career path could be considered a cautionary tale about why you do not want to rush players, especially defensemen, into the NHL. He started playing in San Jose when he was just 21 years old, one season after being drafted. He got off to a great start with the team, posting 21 and 24 points his first two seasons, then bottomed out with 13 in his third season and just three in the fourth. Perhaps his sophomore slump came late, and he took a lot of heat in those two poor seasons for not repeating earlier success. Nevertheless, the Sharks’ coaches have shown slowly increasing faith in him and his performance has improved accordingly. His 34 points last season were a reminder of why expectations were so high for him.

Demers’ role as an offensively-minded defenseman will always make him prone to risk-taking. Much as fans would like to see all the players, forwards and defensemen alike, play a diligent defensive game, playing well at both ends of the ice is harder than it sounds. Well, obviously it sounds pretty hard, barring teleportation powers. Additionally, fans don’t actually enjoy perfect defensive games– those tend to be low-scoring and uneventful. So that’s the cake- eat it or leave it. If Jason Demers is supposed to keep an eye out for scoring chances and even create some, his defensive game might on occasion leave something to be desired.

His contract is eminently reasonable. Looking at the defensemen around Demers in the standings, his salary is lower than most players of equivalent value to their teams. Whether measuring by points or time on ice or age, his $3.4 million per year is a good deal for San Jose. It is such a good deal that one wonders if it isn’t a setup for a trade. The last Shark to file for arbitration (TJ Galiardi) only got one year out of the team, but he was not signed and traded either. For the sake of San Jose, we can hope the Demers contract is not just a set up to move him out.

Taylor Doherty was drafted by the Sharks in the second round in 2009. This year, he will enter his third full season with the AHL’s Worcester Sharks. Last season saw him miss a number of games due to injury, and he has yet to play in the NHL. There was a little more buzz around his name a season ago, but the Sharks obviously think he is worth another look.  Just 23 years old, 6’7″, he has not been heating up the score sheet but last season showed some improvement over the season before. With a little down tick in the +/- column (from +2 to -2), he improved his points total from 6 to 10, playing 23 fewer games. He has a strong shot that he could probably use more often.

Doherty, like Demers… and Braun, and Burns, is a right-handed shot. That is worth noting as such defensemen seem to be in short supply elsewhere.

The Sharks’ offseason is looking like a long slow one, but that is what Doug Wilson promised at the end of last season. If Wilson is serious about not wanting to bring any veteran player in who may supplant younger players, that remaining cap space ($6.145 million, per CapGeek.com) will continue to sit there and taunt those who had hoped for any exciting new additions.