Toronto Blue Jays Daulton Varsho (5) who got injured gets tangled with Sacramento A’s third baseman Max Schuemann (12) after hitting a triple at Rogers Centre in Toronto on Sat May 31, 2025 (Canadian Press via AP)

A’s Fall Short in See-Saw Thriller at Rogers Centre

By Mauricio Segura

In a game that saw no shortage of drama or fireworks, the Sacramento Athletics were narrowly edged out 8-7 by the Blue Jays at Rogers Centre on Saturday the loss extends the Sacramento losing streak to five games. It was a classic back-and-forth affair in which both teams showcased power and precision, but ultimately, the green and gold came up just shy of ending their losing skid.

The Athletics wasted no time making noise. In the top of the first, Jacob Wilson and Brent Rooker reached base to set the stage for Tyler Soderstrom, who launched a three-run blast to center field, his 12th of the year.

It was an early statement that the A’s were in no mood to be passive spectators. Soderstrom has been one of the few bright spots in an A’s offense that, despite struggling lately, is still tied for sixth in the league in slugging percentage.

Yet, Toronto didn’t flinch. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. singled in the bottom of the frame and came home on Addison Barger’s fourth homer of the season. Two walks and a clutch single by Nathan Lukes later, and the Jays had turned a 3-0 deficit into a 4-3 lead before the first inning was done.

The second inning offered a glimpse of hope for the A’s. Luis Urías worked a walk, and Denzel Clarke, playing just his seventh Major League game, crushed his first big league homer to left field, retaking the lead at 5-4. Clarke, who was called up from Triple-A Las Vegas last week, has shown promise with his speed and a .263 average in the minors. The momentum felt palpable.

Unfortunately, it would not last. The A’s have been notorious this season for surrendering long balls, and today was no different. Bo Bichette’s solo shot in the bottom of the second tied things at five, marking the 87th home run allowed by A’s pitchers this season, on pace to break the franchise record of 220.

From there, the Blue Jays kept the pressure on. George Springer went deep in the third and fifth innings, his seventh and eighth of the year, highlighting a four-homer day for Toronto. The A’s bullpen, which entered the game with a 6.10 ERA, continued to falter.

Gunnar Hoglund, making his sixth start of the season, gave up six runs over five innings, struggling with right-handed hitters once again, who are hitting .326 against him this year.

The A’s offense did its best to claw back. Brent Rooker, who had been in a mini-slump earlier in May, belted his 13th homer of the season in the ninth, bringing the A’s within a single run. Tyler Soderstrom doubled with two outs, adding to his multi-hit day. But Shea Langeliers, representing the tying run, lined out to second baseman Ernie Clement, ending the Athletics’ rally and sealing another gut-wrenching loss.

Despite the defeat, there were glimpses of the A’s youthful spark. Lawrence Butler added three hits and a stolen base, extending his streak of successful swipes to eight. Wilson, the leading rookie in Major League Baseball for batting average and RBI, collected another hit to maintain his .344 average, continuing his breakout campaign.

For the Athletics, the loss extends their current road losing streak to nine games, matching their longest in three years. They now sit at 23-36, 12 games under .500, and have dropped 15 of their last 16 contests. The green and gold will look to rookie JP Sears on Sunday to stop the bleeding and salvage the final game of the series.

But in a game marked by dazzling home runs and missed opportunities, Saturday’s thriller was another chapter in a season where the A’s have consistently found themselves one swing, or one pitch, away from victory.

The A’s and Jays close out this series on Sunday. Starting pitcher for Sacramento JP Sears (4-6 ERA 5.18) and for Toronto Kevin Gausman (5-4 ERA 3.68) first pitch 10:37 am PDT.

Costa Rican-born Mauricio Segura has been covering sports in the Bay Area since 2001 for a variety of magazines and newspapers, as well as his own publication, Golden Bay Times.