San Francisco Giants starter Blake Snell leaves for the dugout after being removed in the first inning against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Oracle Park in San Francisco on Thu Sep 5, 2024 (AP News photo)
Thursday, Sept. 5, 2024
Oracle Park
San Francisco, California
Arizona Diamondbacks 2 (79-62)
San Francisco Giants 3 (69-72)
Win: Ryan Walker (9-3)
Loss: Kevin Ginkel (7-3)
Time: 2:35
Attendance: 27,871
By Stephen Ruderman
SAN FRANCISCO–Blake Snell only lasted one inning, but the Giants snapped their four-game skid with a 3-2 win over the Diamondbacks on a walk-off double by Patrick Bailey, who knocked in all three runs for the Giants Thursday.
The Diamondbacks beat the Giants again tonight, 6-4, to take the first two games of this series, as Hayden Birdsong had another outing cut short due to his command, and Zac Gallen threw six no-hit innings to hand the Giants their fourth-straight loss.
Prior to the game, the Giants announced the six-year extension of Matt Chapman through 2030. It is a $151-million deal, in which Chapman will make $25 million a year, as well as a $1-million signing bonus. Chapman sang the praises of the Giants’ organization and the City of San Francisco. He also said that players have called him expressing a desire to come to the Giants.
With Chapman’s extension official, the focus turned to the team on the field. The Giants came into Thursday losers of four-straight games after dropping the first two games of this series. Thursday, they looked to avoid the sweep, and they had the right man on the mound for it in Blake Snell.
However, Snell would have to labor through a long top of the first inning. Geraldo Perdomo lined a base-hit to left field to lead off the game, and Corbin Carroll walked to put runners at first and second with nobody out.
Josh Bell then hit a ground ball to Tyler Fitzgerald, who fielded it while going to his right. Fitzgerald’s momentum was taking him towards third base, where he had a sure out, but he instead threw against his momentum to second. The throw sailed past the second-baseman Brett Wisely, which allowed everyone to move up an extra base, and Perdomo scored.
Snell finally got the first two outs, though he got some help from the boys in the Replay Center in New York on the first one. However, he then walked Eugenio Suarez to load the bases for Jake McCarthy.
Snell fell behind McCarthy 3-0, and then Snell came back to make it 3-2. McCarthy swung and missed at the payoff pitch for strike three, a fastball just off the outside corner, but it was dropped by catcher Patrick Bailey. Bailey couldn’t throw it to first in time; everyone was safe; and the Diamondbacks now led it 2-0.
Merrill Kelly, who had missed four months due to a strained right shoulder, took the ball for Arizona, and he threw a scoreless inning in the bottom of the first.
Bob Melvin decided to lift Snell after just one inning, as the latter had thrown 42 pitches. Landen Roupp was brought in, and he threw a pair of one, two, three innings in the second and third, as well as a scoreless inning in the top of the fourth.
Kelly threw two scoreless innings in the second and third, and then the Giants would mount a rally against him in the bottom of the fourth.
Michael Conforto lined a base-hit to right to start the bottom of the fourth, and Chapman doubled to left to put runners at second at third with no one out. However, LaMonte Wade and Tyler Fitzgerald both struck out swinging, and it looked like the Giants were going to waste another golden opportunity.
Patrick Bailey then came up, and he floated a Texas Leaguer to shallow left to knock in a pair and tie the game.
Arizona then rallied against Roupp in the top of the fifth and put runners at second and third with one out, as they looked to get their lead back. Roupp retired the next two men he faced, and he got out of it without any damage.
Roupp saved the Giants’ bullpen just as Spencer Bivens did last night. Roupp gave up just one hit over four shutout innings. He walked two and struck out five.
Kelly threw a four-pitch one, two, three inning in the bottom of the fifth, and the Giants wasted a leadoff double from Conforto in the top of the sixth. Kelly then threw another one, two, three inning in the bottom of the seventh to cap off a strong start. He gave up six hits, but he didn’t walk anybody, and he struck out eight.
Erik Miller threw a one, two, three inning in the top of the sixth for the Giants, and Tyler Rogers followed that up with a scoreless top of the seventh. Camilo Doval then ran into eighth-inning trouble for the second day in a row.
Christian Walker doubled to right-center to start the inning, as center-fielder Grant McCray was unable to come up with a great catch. Jorge Barrosa bunted Walker over to third, and Doval fell behind Eugenio Suarez 3-1. Doval then came back to strike Suarez out looking, and then Melvin went to his closer, Ryan Walker, who struck out Jake McCarthy to end the inning.
The Giants put runners on first and second with one out against Joe Mantiply in the bottom of the eighth. Heliot Ramos doubled, and then he committed a base-running gaffe, which thanks to a bad throw by Mantiply on a comebacker to the mound, allowed Conforto to reach first. Torey Lovullo brought in Kevin Ginkel, and Ginkel got out of the inning without any damage.
The game was still tied 2-2 going to the ninth. Melvin sent Walker back out for the top of the ninth, and Luis Guillorme drew a leadoff walk, the worst possible thing that could happen for Walker and the Giants. However, Walker then retired the side in order to give the Giants a chance to win it in the bottom of the ninth.
Ginkel was back out for Arizona in the bottom of the ninth. Tyler Fizgerald led off the inning with a base-hit to center, and he stole second with Bailey at the plate.
Bailey, who knocked in the first two runs for the Giants with a Texas Leaguer in the bottom of the fourth, came through again, as he hit a ground-rule double to left-center to win it for the Giants. It was the Giants’ league-leading 11th walk-off win of the year.
Ryan Walker was rewarded with the win for his clutch late-inning performance. Kevin Ginkel took the loss for the Diamondbacks.
On Aug. 31, 2018, the Giants shut out the Mets 7-0 to improve to 68-68. The Giants then lost 11-straight games before finally winning their 69th game. It was the beginning of a brutal 5-21 finish to the 2018 Season for the Giants that cost then-General Manager Bobby Evans his job.
Fast forward six years later with Farhan Zaidi facing uncertainty over his future. The Giants beat the Miami Marlins 3-1 on Aug. 30 to improve to 68-68. The Giants then only lost four-straight to get that elusive 69th win.
During Matt Chapman’s press conference, Giants President of Baseball Operations Farhan Zaidi was asked about his future with the team. Zaidi declined to answer the question, and he deferred the topic of conversation back to that of Chapman’s extension.
Despite being signed to a contract extension through 2026, there has been speculation that Zaidi’s job could be in danger. Alex Pavlovic, the Giants Beat Writer for NBC Sports Bay Area, hinted on July 25 that people in the Giants’ front office needed them to make the playoffs this season.
With the fact that this season has not panned out like everyone had hoped, and that the Giants are wrapping up their third-straight season of mediocracy, Zaidi’s fate could come into the spotlight over the final three and a half weeks of the season.
The Giants improve to 69-72, and they will head down the coast to San Diego Friday for a three-game series against another powerful team in the Padres. The pitching matchup has yet to be decided. First pitch will be at 6:40 p.m PT.

